Jo H2O Anal Thick 4 oz.

I was worried a water-based lube would get tacky fast, but this one kept gliding the whole time. The extra thickness gives way more cushion than the thinner stuff I've used, and it cleans up easily with just water.

That thickness is no joke — it stays put instead of dripping everywhere like the thinner stuff I used before. Being five times thicker than the usual formula really does make a difference for cushioning.

The thickness is real, definitely five times thicker than the standard anal formula, so it stays where you put it. But it gets tacky after a while and I had to reapply more often than I'd like, even with the 4 oz bottle.